FLAGSTAFF, Ariz. — A massive thinning project in northern Arizona’s
forests is now in the hands of another contractor that plans to use the
harvested trees to produce wood pellets, furniture and biodiesel fuel, officials
Pioneer Forest Products was selected in 2012 to thin 300,000 acres in four
Arizona forests over 10 years. But the Montana-based company had trouble with
financing and talked to the U.S. Forest Service earlier this year about
transferring its contract.
The Forest Service on Friday announced the approval of a transfer to Good Earth
Power AZ LLC., whose parent company in Oman primarily does work outside the U.S.
Forest officials said they determined that Good Earth is financially and
technically sound to carry out the work.
The stewardship contract that the Forest Service has called the largest in its
history is meant to restore a 2.4 million-acre area along the Mogollon Rim to
reduce wildfire risks and create sustainable forest industries.
The Forest Service has acknowledged the project is behind schedule. An order to
treat about 930 acres on the Apache Sitgreaves National Forest is expected to
wrap up soon. Four other task orders covering about 5,700 acres on the Apache
Sitgreaves and Kaibab forests were issued this week.
Conservationists, scientists, timber industry representatives, and local and
forest officials worked together to shape the project known as 4FRI. Already,
some are raising concerns about the new contractor and its business plan that
includes logging large-diameter trees.
Kaibab National Forest supervisor Mike Williams said most of the thinning will
involve small-diameter trees, but there will be a need to create openings in the
forest by removing trees that are larger than 16 inches in diameter.
Environmental groups have been fighting against that in court since the early
“They’re forcing us to go back into the trenches to protect the last of the
large trees,” said Robin Silver, co-founder of the Center for Biological
Diversity. “I can’t imagine how you would work harder to destroy 4FRI but to
pick another contractor with no experience and now focused on large trees.
Good Earth global chief executive Jason Rosamond said the company has no
experience with forest restoration in the Southwest but has brought on an
undisclosed forest management company that does. Good Earth also retained
Pioneer employee Marlin Johnson, who previously has worked for the Forest
The company’s plan is to work with local mills and invest in some of them so
they have the capacity to take the harvested products. Rosamond said Good Earth
also will invest in about 20 pellet mills scattered throughout the project area
and ship the product overseas. A $50 million mill in Winslow and a power plant
to produce synthetic gas that can be converted into biodiesel and jet fuel are
part of the company’s plans.
Rosamond said the conversion technology hasn’t been tested on a large scale,
but “we’re confident we’re going to get it right.” The financially viability
of the project isn’t dependent on it, he said.
Navajo County Supervisor David Tenney said he and other local leaders plan to
meet with Good Earth on Monday to discuss the company’s business plan _
something he said they could not get Pioneer to agree to. He said he’s
encouraged that Good Earth appears to have solid financing.
“I just want the forest treated. I’ve been calling on the Forest Service to
issue the task orders and hold their contractor responsible,” he said. “This
seems to be a step in the right direction.”