PHOENIX — A federal judge has dismissed several claims in a lawsuit filed
against Attorney General Tom Horne and an aide by a criminal investigator in
their office but is allowing others to proceed.
Wednesday’s decision by U.S. District Judge David Campbell allows defamation
and conspiracy claims made by Margaret Hinchey to go forward against Horne and
Chief Deputy Attorney General Richard Bistrow. But it dismisses negligence,
invasion of privacy, discipline without cause and several other claims.
Hinchey sued in January, alleging that Horne and Bistrow retaliated against her
after she told the FBI that the state’s top prosecutor may have participated in
illegal campaign activities.
Horne has denied the allegations. Spokeswoman Stephanie Grisham says he and
Bistrow are confident the remainder of the accusations will also eventually be