PHOENIX — The prosecutor’s office in Apache County is warning a newly
appointed state senator that it will seek to remove him from office if he can’t
prove he meets residency requirements.
The letter sent to Sen. Carlyle Begay by the Apache County Attorney’s Office
advises him to get a lawyer and provide proof of residency or it will seek a
court order removing him from office.
The letter is in response to state Rep. Albert Hale’s challenge to Begay’s
appointment by the Apache County Board of Supervisors. Begay claims residency in
the Apache County community of Ganado, but Hale’s lawyer has provided documents
to the county attorney’s office that he says prove Begay actually has lived in
the Maricopa County town of Gilbert for the past seven years.
State law requires lawmakers to have lived for at least a year in the county
Begay did not immediately respond to calls or emails seeking comment Tuesday.
He has previously said he meets the residency requirement for appointment to the
Begay was appointed and sworn in Aug. 6 to replace a senator who resigned. Hale
also applied for the appointment. All are Democrats.
Hale’s lawyer sent a legal demand for action to the Apache County attorney and
Arizona attorney general last week. The letter included documents showing Begay
listed his residence as Gilbert in application for a town board earlier this
year. He also told lawmakers he was a Gilbert resident during confirmation
hearings for a state board appointment in January.
Proving he lives in Ganado should not be hard _ if he really does, Hale
attorney Tom Ryan said. Begay could show utility bills, a driver’s license or a
“There’s a lot of evidence he can provide showing where his residence was,”
Ryan said Tuesday. “My guess is he only has evidence that he has lived in
Gilbert for the last 7 1/2 years.”